Re: VMs: evidence against line transposition

["Michael R. Breese" <ftmrb@xxxxxxx>]

I like your idea: if we were so smart, why haven't we figured it out yet? 
We may not be asking the right questions.  But, as a geologist with an
unhealthy interest in crypto, I'm completely unqualified to comment on
your methods - or anybody else's for that matter.  Which is why I lurk.

Cheers!

>  Wayne Durden <wdurden@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> April 1,2005
>  wrote:
> (snip).....
> ... ...
>
>  On another note, I was somewhat disappointed this morning that there was
>  little comment on the public list about the graphic I posted, yet I
> received
>  six direct off list expressions of interest.  When I checked the hit log
> for
>  the site at which I posted the graphic, there are a rather large number
> of
>  hits and several folks crawled the images directory (there were no other
>  related images there, only my second grade sons photos for a web page
> media
>  project, although I will pull together some other examples and post them
> as
>  there seems to be interest).  This makes me wonder if this list is truly
> a
>  good way to solicit honest public feedback.  I was hoping maybe even
> three
>  or four folks might say I see no similarity there other than what I see
>  elsewhere in the manuscript and I believe you are chasing cloud bunnies,
> or
>  an opinion that yes, it looks somewhat interesting to me.  There was
> nothing
>  like that on the public list, and even Nick, whose comment resulted in
> the
>  post, didn't directly opine afterward? Was this politeness Nick?  I can
> take
>  anyone's honest opinion on the issue, and would welcome opinions that cut
>  off an avenue of effort I am chasing. Yet off the list I got comments
>  pointing out in my color markings I left out more similarities like the
> "am"
>  form or even the whole word after "ocar"...  Or suggestions that applying
> a
>  fuzzy analysis to the EVA transcript does turn up larger phrases.  What
>  gives?
>
>
>  I have a thick skin, etc.. etc..
> ......(END SNIP)
>
>  For what it's worth...WLD
>
> Jeeze WLD :-) (give me some time here (ha.ha))
>
> I just got BOTH of your mails today, I'm assuming your talking about
> your color 'underlined' two seperate pages for cross-comparison??
> I will only apologies for myself, but I don't sit on the computer
> all-day anymore... (tried that for 7-8 yrs and got a big clout filled
> left leg, that doc says will come off if i don't move it daily),
> ANYWAY I ALSO use a mail reader here, (PINE), that doesn't support
> graphics (for spam reasons), so I sent your ~little visited?~ website
> addy to my wifes computer... she uses MS (ugghh) for viewing... I'm
> hoping to be totally amazed by your multi-colored _underlined_
> assesments, but just going through the mail here (from yesterday & now
> today) I've not even had a chance to VIEW IT YET!!  (oh the ~seeing~
> of bunnies in the cloud on this list is OK... IF you can truly show
> something that the others haven't or cannot shoot down!?
>  The list is ~Blessed~ with many a unique minds, and I suspect many
> participate (if only on the weekends) as a hobby, side-interest or
> when they have time?? D*rN those day jobs anyway! (ha.ha)
>
> Well, in about 30 minutes from now I'm off to the other computer to
> *SEE* your reference(s)... IF I have something to say, I will say it,
> IF I don't understand it or disagree I probable won't say anything :-o
> Don't take it personally, I'm one of the ~dummies of the list~.
>
> I started from the TOP down, instead of from the BOTTOM up etc..
>
> I would suggest(?) if I might, that you give this list (and it's 'open
> to all - membership ) consideration of a vms Supreme Court. It has
> been my experience that the incoming will either leave or be shot down
> in their own right, while the questionable (to the open-minded
> members) will have to pass the ~mustard~, as it were.  EVERYONE has an
> idea here, everyone is ~searching~. Coders, Linguist, Treasure
> hunters, male / female, young and old alike. I guess I'm just trying
> to say "Patience"... and IF you are not heard, or wonder if your idea
> even got through, YOU CAN USE ALL CAPitols (He.he), which most members
> will
> probably say ~shhh or yes yes - we saw/heard you!~ as they boil and
> formulate the big picture.
>
> p.s. after 30 minutes here (after reviewing your page)... I plan to go
> outside and walk this ~stupid LEFT leg~ of mine... I promise you, I
> will ~churn~ whatever I find over in my meer brain here.
>
> I do LOVE "anything" voynich related... many are over my head here,
> but the chase is ON and will be until ~cracked~!! (period).
>
> This is not just to you (nothing personal), but archived for all who
> *see* the vms for the first time and SEE IT!  There is ~muster to
> pass~ and this is a fine list if you can do it!  Many will provide
> guidence many will ~curse & howl~ most remain behind the scenes,(I
> know whoo Yoo Arr (!))
> putting the pieces _slowly_ together for themselves... expect a 2-3
> week window for good ideas to fully ~bloom~ as it were. (?)
>
> best to you & yours
> -=se=-
> steve (folding the vms) ekwall :-)
>
> p.s.s. If someone (maybe two) would fully shot down my ~folding the
> vms idea~ I would leave the list and let you all play on, but it must
> have been important or I wouldn't have been ~touched~ by it..
>
> Good day all :-)
>
> ______________________________________________________________________
> To unsubscribe, send mail to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxx with a body saying:
> unsubscribe vms-list
>



______________________________________________________________________
To unsubscribe, send mail to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxx with a body saying:
unsubscribe vms-list