[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

VMs: Re: f68v3 ("Andromeda") and it's T-O map...?

Hi Jorge,

> I find it hard to look at that page and not think of the T-O map
> representing the earth, and the Wolkenband representing the Milky Way, with
> a linear sequence of stars strung out along the ecliptic - like 22 pearls
> on a necklace.

The surrounding dotted area (which is blue in the Yale color images)
could be the sky, except that its boundary looks more like the edge of
a pool. Also the spiral arms look like four roads with bridges over
the pool, alternating with four water channels that feed into (or draw
from) the pool.

I believe that the realization that spiral galaxies are assemblages of stars
is quite modern (18th century?); and the idea of the Earth being *within*
such a galaxy is newer still.  If that is what f68v3 shows, then
move over, Vinland Map...


I think the explanation is much simpler: within a sequence of cosmological images, the author felt that the relationship of the earth to the fixed stars needed to be included as well. I don't think it represents what we now think of a "galaxy", except in so far as there is an ecliptic line of fixed stars (which we now conceptualise as "looking along the Milky Way's galactic plane").

Having said that, I don't have an explanation for the diagram's "spiral arms", so who knows? :-)

Another candidate for T-O map is f86v3, the "garden of eden", where
the T-O map is obviously incomplete.  Is it an unfinished sketch? A scribal
mistake? A palimpsest? Or a chance survival of a more complex figure,
which has faded away?

<...> This page, by the way, is a
panel of the big fold-out, which is a quire by itself; and in fact
f86v3 is the panel which would be the "back cover" of that quire, when
it was completely folded. Thus it is understandable that it has
suffered a lot more wear than the rest of the VMS.)

I'd guess that the various marks on f86v3 bled across onto the page from a later scribe's nearly-but-not-quite-completely-dry writing, upon which the quire had accidentally been placed. :-/

Cheers, .....Nick Pelling.....