[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: VMs: Cardan Grille

Rene Zandbergen r_zandbergen@xxxxxxxxx wrote

> --- "David R. Jones" <drjones@xxxxxxx> wrote:
> > This was recently posted to another group, and I
> > thought it might be of
> > interest here.  I know that Cardan and Dee were
> > associates, though they
> > had a falling out at one point.  My main point was
> > if anyone had seen
> > this in the context of the Voynich MS and if they
> > found the arguments
> > presented convincing.
> Yes, the originator of the theory (Gordon Rugg)
> has been in communication with all of us on
> this list and I assume that he is still around.
> (Nicely organised site, by the way, Gordon!)
> I wonder if you would be able to tell me (us :-) )
> how a Cardan grille would have normally been
> used in the times of Dee. Was it a cryptographic
> device? Would it be to scramble text, or to be
> able to select only certain words from a text?
> To answer your question: I am personally not
> convinced that the VMs could have been generated
> in the manner described. What might convince me
> is if he managed to define a table, set up with some
> kind of logic behind it, which actually does
> reproduce some part of the MS text. Currently,
> table fagments I have seen are set up in order
> to duplicate the known statistical properties
> of the text, but without any order or rule.
> Apart from that, I wouldn't exclude the
> possibility that the VMs contains meaningless
> text and is a hoax in one way or another.
> Kind regards, Rene

Well I think I know how to set up several systems to duplicate the VMS but
what would it prove?

I've just thought of something! I'm going to check it out.


To unsubscribe, send mail to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxx with a body saying:
unsubscribe vms-list