Re: VMs: The construction of voynichese words

["jan" <hurychj@xxxxxxxxx>]

Hello Francisco,

did  you get your method (prefix-midfix-suffix) patented? Since Gordion Ruggs claims it is his, see 

 http://www.keele.ac.uk/depts/cs/staff/g.rugg/voynich/cardan.html
http://www.economist.com/science/displayStory.cfm?story_id=2329803 

Of course he uses the grill, you use Lull's circular gadget, but what is the real difference? or are your  fragments same as his?

Now the serious question: Do you consider the VM gibbrish or not? Because we can create VM words in  many  interesting ways already, but  what do we get as a result? Sensically unconnected fractions? Ruggs claims now he has  the proof the VM is gibberish. Do you claim your  prefix-midfix-suffix  is   also just a  gibb-er-ish?  If yes, 
then you just doing the same Ruggs does, if not, what sense does  those mutants have? 

Jan
  
  
=======  You wrote:  
>(Or how to repeat all the Manuscript with a single analogic device...)
>
>Hi all!
>
>About the construction on voynichese words in basis of 3 components
>(prefix-midfix-suffix),  the lasts October, 1, I was finished a
>?document? (a ?serious? but amusing work: 18 pages and 7 figures) about
>the Manuscript, sent already to Internet -web Casanchi- (I wait only the
>web adress to send this datum to Voynich list).
>
>In this work I present an ?analogic device?, inspired in the book ?Ars
>Magna et ultima? (Llull): in this opus we can see some ?artifacts? with
>capital letters. A ?mechanically circular drawn? with astronomical
>designs (animals) we can see in a miniature of ?Le breviare d? amour?:
>this draw shows 12 sectors -in the outer ring- with labels (the names of
>the months in French); but the inner sectors are text: a ring of text
>like MVs... Other astronomical ?mechanically circular drawn? we can see
>in ?Libros del Saber de Astronomía?: a ring with text about the stars of
>the constellations. (But  the astronomical draw of folio f67r1 contain
>too the key of this new device!...)
>
>Now, tanx to Anthony, we can see on-line all this pics in:
>
>http://hawcross.net/voynich/VMS.htm
>
>Well, shortly and in other words: with this easy device (the use is more
>fast and easy that Cardano?s grating from Dr. Rugg!) I can to repeat ALL
>the text of MVs, building long words like in voynichese (prefix + midfix
>+ suffix), shorts (none + none + suffix) or medium (none + midfix +
>suffix or also prefix + none + suffix).
>
>Please, to be patient!: perhaps tomorrow I have the definitive web
>adress and I send this datum to the list for to download (in PDF format)
>this work. I was offer a copy of my work to review ?Investigacion y
>Ciencia?, the Spanish version of ?Scientific American?, for to compare
>with the article of Dr. Rugg, and to the French review ?The Recherche?.
>
>A greeting,
>
>Francisco Violat Bordonau
>Observatorio Astronómico de Caceres (Spain)
>______________________________________________________________________
>To unsubscribe, send mail to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxx with a body saying:
>unsubscribe vms-list

= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
 


______________________________________________________________________
To unsubscribe, send mail to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxx with a body saying:
unsubscribe vms-list