Re: VMs: RE: The key

["Jeff" <jeff@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

Can you send a link to your website. I would be very interested to see your
method.

And for John Grove. I know people get heated about claims of solution. They
have invested a lot of time and effort and know how tricky this stuff is. I
have seen various things proposed on list and then they seem to disappear.
Some of the most interesting are never discussed with enough openness.
People seem to protective of their own methods. This is why I reviewed my
emails a while back and came across several things of very great interest.
There I some on the list who seem to have disappeared and I would like to
know how they are progressing. I am not in this for recognition. I just like
a chalenge. I do not adhere to the principle of peer review. Sorry but I
don't. If I solve it I solve it. If I don't then that's too bad. But I will
know when I've done it and so will everyone else.

Jeff

john stojko oko@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
On 17 February 2004 21:29


>
> John, your suggestion to Jeff is not fair. " Why aren't you arguing that
> John Stojko's
> translation of the VMS is correct and that he has solved the VMS? "
>
> My solution does not need any argument - it is transparent. But you
> suggested that Jeff should, I would like to suggest how it should be done.
>
>   1.. He should learn Voynich alphabet given in my Home Page.
>   2.. He should have some knowledge of Ukrainian language.
>   3.. Now he will be able to read the VMs text and made his conclusion for
> or against my decipherment.
>
>
> If he does not know Ukrainian, his effort will be wasted. He may learn the
> alphabet and by following my example, transliterate Voynich alphabet
> consisting of consonants, into Ukrainian or English alphabet. But that is
> not all. He has to add vowels. If he knows Ukrainian the vowels will be
> added as required in Ukrainian language. If does not know Ukrainian, the
> vowels will be added according to his judgment based on his knowledge of
his
> language or believe. The final result will be nothing else but gibberish
> writings.
>
>
>
> Jeff believes that his approach leads to final solution. Obviously his
> approach differs from my, yours and many others. But at this stage where
he
> is, it is too early to make any judgment. Let him believe and work. I do
> respect people that believe because, believe is not the truth but it is
key
> to success and to the final truth. Once he reaches the final
conclusion-the
> truth- he will stop to believe. Until than, he should be encouraged not
> discouraged.
>
>
>
> John stojko
>
>


______________________________________________________________________
To unsubscribe, send mail to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxx with a body saying:
unsubscribe vms-list